Blog

Legislating Social Privacy
July 30, 2010
There’s a great deal of talk these days about privacy and social media. Specifically, services like Google, Facebook, Twitter, and other popular social networking platforms are coming under increased scrutiny over their privacy policies and data sharing practices. Permalink

When Privileged Access is no longer a Privilege
July 19, 2010
I just read an interesting multi-part investigative report in the Washington Post about how intelligence gathering – and the bureaucracy that has risen since September 11, 2001 to facilitate the harvest and analysis of that information – has spun beyond the federal government’s control, not to mention its ability to make use of the sheer abundance of information. Permalink

Information Governance in the Cloud
July 15, 2010
Just a brief note to bring our recent webinar to your attention.  I presented Information Governance in the Cloud along with the good people at Symantec. Permalink

Home » Blog » Mike Spinney's Blog » Consumer Influences on Most Trusted for Privacy » 

RSS Feed

RSS Feed RSS Feed

Consumer Influences on Most Trusted for Privacy

March 4, 2010

FoxBusiness.com called the other day asking if we might be interested in talking about our annual Most Trusted Companies for Privacy study. Always eager to promote our research (the Institute, after all, produces the most interesting privacy and information security research in the land), I said yes. It’s a busy time for us – Larry was knee-deep in RSA, and I was scheduled to give a talk on privacy in online social networking – but we made arrangements for me to make a brief stop in Hartford, Connecticut where I would do a remote live shot.
 
The producer passed along a brief overview of the topics that hosts Chris Cotter and Tracy Byrnes wanted to discuss, so I arrived early and got myself ready in the green room, anticipating what questions might be asked and practicing pithy responses (as well as keeping my hands from their usual wild gesticulations). Wired for the interview, a producer in New York told me I was up next and the fun began.
 
As a privacy professional who is immersed most days in issues related to information security and data breach, I had given a lot of thought to how our findings might relate to the public’s concerns about becoming the victims of credit fraud and identity theft, but it became clear early on that Cotter and Byrnes, besides being professional journalists asking good business questions, were regular folks who had a more common interest in the subject.
 
Byrnes, for example, commented on the “kooky” idea of Google providing satellite imagery of her home and the abundance of information entered into that popular search engine each day. Then came the question I hadn’t considered: how did Weight Watchers end up on our list of twenty most trusted brands?
 
It was at that moment that it struck me that our annual Most Trusted Companies for Privacy survey is as much about American consumer culture as it is about brand trust. We are a people obsessed by weight, and in spite of study after study showing Americans to be growing heavier and heavier, we are nevertheless in search of ways to shed those pounds, to the point where a brand like Weight Watchers can achieve broad enough saturation to not only eclipse our threshold for consideration, but make the top twenty. I quip that this may say something about the growing corpulence of the American population, but there’s truth to that notion.
 
Each year since our benchmark 2005 study there are changes to the list that are a clear reflection of events or trends affecting consumers.
 
  • In 2006, even as major data breaches were becoming regular headline fodder, investment firm Charles Schwab made the list, possibly a reflection of their groundbreaking campaign of guaranteeing investor funds against any theft caused by the company’s negligence.
  • In 2007, at the height of the real estate bubble, Countrywide made the list, likely driven by that company’s aggressive position in the mortgage industry. Many consumers took advantage of Countrywide’s services to purchase homes and investment properties. There was reason for trust and optimism, but the company was beset by financial troubles later that year and in 2008 scandal rocked the company. Bank of America agreed to purchase the company in 2008, but it is unlikely that Countrywide would have made the list because…
  • In 2008, with the collapse of the markets, many financial services firms suffered on our Most Trusted list. Bank of America, which acquired troubled Countrywide, fell off and other firms dropped significantly. Meanwhile Facebook, which had become a mainstream brand, made its debut having shown itself to be responsive to consumer concerns over privacy missteps with its Beacon advertising platform. Conversely Google, which had made the list the two previous years, failed to make the top twenty in 2008 most likely because of questions related to a public debate over search data retention and Street View imagery.
  • In 2009 Google made its return, but Facebook dropped off, a seemingly obvious response to outcry over changes to the service’s privacy and security settings which drew harsh criticism from many consumer advocates, but which forced users to address the issue in order to participate. The timing for Facebook was poor in terms of this survey – which launched while the kerfuffle was at its peak – but as I said on Fox, that transparent approach to privacy and the company’s typical responsiveness to public comment will, I believe, serve it well in the long run.
 
Here’s a chart of the results of our Must Trusted Companies for Privacy survey over the last five years. What conclusions can you draw? Let us know.
 

Publication year
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
 
Date field work completed
Dec 2009
Nov 2008
Dec 2007
Dec 2006
Oct 2005
Five Year Average
American Express
1
1
1
1
2
 1.2
IBM
2
3
3
8
7
 4.6
Johnson & Johnson
3
5
6
14
14
 8.4
Hewlett Packard
4
6
16
4
5
 7.0
E-Bay
5
2
8
5
1
 4.2
US Postal Service
6
6
7
7
6
 6.4
Procter & Gamble
7
7
9
3
3
 5.8
Amazon
8
4
5
2
4
 4.6
Nationwide
8
9
9
NR
NR
 8.7
USAA
9
11
15
20
NR
 13.8
WebMD
10
13
12
NR
NR
 11.7
Intuit
11
12
19
NR
NR
 14.0
Apple
12
8
NR
NR
NR
 10.0
Disney
12
16
15
20
11
 14.8
Google
13
NR
10
10
NR
 11.0
Verizon
14
17
NR
NR
NR
 15.5
Charles Schwab
15
10
2
12
NR
 9.8
Facebook
NR
15
NR
NR
NR
 15.0
US Bank
15
19
17
NR
14
 16.3
Weight Watchers
16
NR
20
13
19
 17.0
Yahoo
17
14
4
6
NR
 10.3
FedEx
18
18
NR
NR
NR
 18.0
Dell
20
20
13
8
10
 14.2
Walmart
20
NR
NR
NR
NR
 20.0
AT&T
20
NR
NR
NR
NR
 20.0
AOL
NR
16
4
6
NR
 8.7
ELoan
NR
20
11
16
17
 16.0
Countrywide
NR
NR
14
NR
NR
 14.0
Bank of America
NR
NR
18
NR
12
 15.0

 
*Please note that publication year is always one year later than field work year because of the timing of field research.
NR denotes not ranked in the top 20 in the given year.

Posted by Mike Spinney at 8:35 pm


Add Comment (1 comments)

Comments

March 10, 2010 2:22pm Trey

Hi Mike, How come in Ponemon's press release it mentions that AmEx has topped the list for 5 consecutive years, but your graph only shows 4? +++++ Good catch, Trey, but nothing sinister; just a simple mistake on the release. Mike